Archives

2025

Cost, Care & Lifespan

Comparing Concrete and Fibreglass Pools

When it comes to creating the perfect backyard oasis, choosing the right type of swimming pool can make all the difference. The two most popular options homeowners often compare are concrete vs fibreglass pools. Both come with their own advantages and drawbacks, especially when it comes to cost, care requirements, and long-term durability.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know to make an informed decision between concrete and fibreglass pools—from initial installation costs to maintenance, aesthetics, and lifespan.

1. Installation and Initial Cost

Concrete Pools

Concrete pools are known for their flexibility in design. They can be custom-built to any shape or size, which makes them ideal for homeowners with unique landscaping ideas or irregular yard shapes. However, that flexibility comes at a price.

• Installation Time: Typically 8–12 weeks.

• Initial Cost: On average, $50,000–$100,000+, depending on complexity.

Concrete pools are built from scratch, involving excavation, steel reinforcement, concrete spraying (usually gunite or shotcrete), curing, tiling, and plastering. This extensive process contributes to higher initial costs and longer timelines.

Fibreglass Pools

Fibreglass pools are pre-manufactured shells that are delivered in one piece and installed into a pre-dug hole.

• Installation Time: Usually 1–3 weeks.

• Initial Cost: On average, $30,000–$70,000.

Because they are factory-made, fibreglass pools come in a variety of standard shapes and sizes. The quicker installation timeline means fewer labour hours, which contributes to lower upfront costs compared to concrete.

Verdict: If time and budget are primary concerns, fibreglass pools often offer better value during the installation phase.

2. Customisation and Aesthetics

Concrete Pools

In terms of design flexibility, concrete is the clear winner. You can customise virtually every aspect of the pool:

• Size

• Shape

• Depth

• Integrated features like tanning ledges, beach entries, or infinity edges

Finishes can also vary—plaster, tile, pebble, or even glass bead options let you fine-tune the aesthetic to match your vision.

Fibreglass Pools

Fibreglass pools come in set moulds, so your options for customisation are limited. While there are many modern, attractive designs available, you’re restricted to the manufacturer's catalogue. However, most models still include features like built-in steps, benches, and even tanning shelves.

Verdict: If you want a one-of-a-kind, luxury design, concrete pools take the lead in customisation.

3. Maintenance & Care

Concrete Pools

Concrete is porous, meaning algae and bacteria can easily find places to grow if not properly maintained. This makes concrete pools more demanding in terms of:

• Chemical Use: Higher levels of chlorine and acid are often needed.

• Surface Maintenance: Surfaces need to be brushed weekly to prevent algae.

• Resurfacing: Usually required every 10–15 years, which can be costly.

Fibreglass Pools

Fibreglass has a non-porous gelcoat surface that resists algae and bacteria, which drastically reduces the amount of maintenance required.

• Chemical Use: Requires fewer chemicals to maintain balance.

• Cleaning: Simple brushing and skimming is often sufficient.

• Surface Durability: Can last decades without resurfacing if properly maintained.

Verdict: Fibreglass pools are easier and cheaper to maintain over time, making them ideal for low-maintenance households.

4. Durability and Lifespan

Concrete Pools

When properly maintained, concrete pools are incredibly durable and can last 50+ years. However, this longevity comes with the trade-off of periodic major maintenance like resurfacing and re-tiling.

• Pros: Strong structure, long lifespan.

• Cons: Higher long-term maintenance costs.

Fibreglass Pools

Modern fibreglass pools are also long-lasting, typically 25–30 years, and in many cases even longer. While the shell itself is durable, the gelcoat can fade or blister over time, especially if not maintained or if exposed to harsh elements.

• Pros: Excellent resistance to cracking and movement.

• Cons: Limited repair options if structural damage occurs.

Verdict: Concrete edges out fibreglass in terms of lifespan, but fibreglass pools still offer a strong balance between durability and low maintenance.

5. Environmental Impact

Concrete Pools

The construction process for concrete pools consumes more materials and energy, and their higher chemical usage increases environmental impact over time. The porous surface can also lead to more frequent water draining for cleaning.

Fibreglass Pools

Fibreglass pools are considered more environmentally friendly due to:

• Shorter construction timelines

• Lower chemical usage

• Reduced energy costs for cleaning and heating

Verdict: Fibreglass pools are more eco-friendly overall, especially in terms of water and chemical usage.

6. Comfort and Feel

Concrete Pools

Concrete surfaces can be rough on the feet, particularly if the finish is plaster. Pebble or tile finishes are more comfortable but add to the cost. Rough textures can also be harsh on swimsuits and skin over time.

Fibreglass Pools

Fibreglass shells have a smooth, non-abrasive finish. This makes them more comfortable for swimmers, especially children or those with sensitive skin.

Verdict: Fibreglass wins in terms of swimmer comfort.

7. Long-Term Value and Resale

While both types of pools can add value to your home, their appeal depends on your local market.

• In luxury or custom-home markets, a bespoke concrete pool might have more appeal.

• In suburban or mid-range markets, a low-maintenance fibreglass pool could be a more attractive selling point.

Also, prospective buyers often consider maintenance costs and effort. Fibreglass pools’ low upkeep can be a strong selling feature.

Verdict: Fibreglass pools often offer better value for typical homebuyers, but concrete may have the edge in high-end markets.

Final Comparison: Concrete vs Fibreglass Pools

Conclusion: Which Pool is Right for You?

When comparing concrete vs fibreglass pools, the best choice comes down to your priorities:

• If you’re seeking complete design freedom and are willing to invest more time and money upfront (and down the line), a concrete pool may be the better choice.

• If you prefer quicker installation, easier maintenance, and a smoother swimming experience, a fibreglass pool is likely the best fit.

In either case, understanding the cost, care, and lifespan of each pool type will help you make a decision that suits your lifestyle and long-term goals.

No matter which option you choose, both concrete and fibreglass pools can provide years of enjoyment and enhance your property’s value—when selected with care.

by aniksk33 on 2025-10-01 12:24:55