I see what's happening now! Go into your CNAME setting again and switch out aed.gamerlaunch.com with customdomain1.guildlaunch.com. That should start pointing it at the correct place where it will get the SSL.
No worries, it's one of the least intuitive things we do here. I want to make this system better, but SSL certs are complicated. I'm happy we got you sorted out though, looks like your cert is working now!